Really? I mean sure, he wouldn't win FISM with that. But really, bad? I don't really think it was that bad at all. So you are saying that your average lay audience they would not be satisfied with that kind of act?

I'm no expert on glass/prop manipulation, but I'm pretty sure it's not like we could give explanation of that act to lay person and have the practice for weeks and pull of anything close to that.

The rest is not comment for you specifically:

Watching some magic videos recently I'm just so sick seeing literally everyone being called bad for slightest inaccuracies in the acts. It's same shit that you see in sports people saying like NBA players who aren't absolute superstars just suck and so on.

I don't know what's it with people with so often the mindset that if you are not the absolute best you're just trash. The thing is whether you're magician or athlete or something else. If you can do whatever it is that you do for living year after year, then you probably are pretty solid.

As for this act. I don't know where you have been, but the couple of magic clubs I've seen in countries that I've lived so far that kind of act would be top quality and for sure would get bookings. I think it's overall very solid act put together. Sure it has room for improving in many different areas, but it's already easily clean enough to be performed and to be asking money for.