I’m mistaken what I saw as the drip rail is the door I’m assuming was replaced. Did you not mention something about the out of network shop saving $2k that you used towards non accident related repairs? I didn’t read every comment if your last post but that’s what I gathered. That roof should have been replaced based off the photo you posted. The reason the roof should have been replaced and if Toyota saw the before and after of the repair they would have said yeah we wouldn’t have approved repairing that roof.

In my opinion you and the other shop are in the wrong here. That shop shouldn’t have tried to repair that roof and you are expecting perfection after requesting improper repairs.