Allah knows the future/everything right?

I didn't say that Hitchens support my argument but at least he never makes simple fallacies as you do, in fact I never come across anyone to does that.

We are talking over each other here, let's make sure we are using same definitions. When you say free will, what does that entails?

Free will means ability to choose between two options rationally and know what each option is or what it foresee.

Let's say that you rob a bank, you can earn billions or get caught, so you measure both options and pick which logically seems better for you <----- this is what I mean by free will.

When a student chooses between doing homework or having fun with friends, they make conscious decision and live the consequences. God isn't controlling your decisions.

/r/islam Thread Parent