The Witcher 3: beautiful graphics, writing so good that even the side quests are engaging and all involve player choice, believable characters, a gritty world that feels alive, dlc packs the size of some full AAA games, and has a decent bit of humor so it isn’t all depressing (though it can be at times due to the situations and themes explored).

Borderlands 2: pretty good story but not too much in terms of player choice, satisfying gunplay, pretty funny but can still pull off emotional moments when the situation calls for it, and has a ton of DLC.

Fallout New Vegas: kinda outdated but has a really fitting atmosphere, well done dark humor, believable characters, and an almost excessive amount of player choice.