The problem isn’t PVP. The problem is that it’s very easy for someone with creative mode enabled to dump stuff into another player’s inventory. It’s also very easy to steamroll players in PVP which I’ve seen people take rather seriously.

For me personally it makes literally no difference because I’m not into PVP and I’ve been playing this game long enough to care about stuff being dumped into my inventory. But, it seems that these difficulty settings have split the community and it’s not a bad idea to have split lobbies for it the way most other games do. It’s just a thought. All I really want is for everyone to enjoy the game.