The question is flawed because none of them can really be considered a failure. Sure, none of these folks have turned into Oscar-caliber actors or actresses (hell, how many “real actors” can even manage that?) but they have all been in high profile projects that made money at the box office, and Harry Styles for example has worked with both Marvel and Christopher Nolan.

To be honest, this just feels like a cheap way to dunk on pop stars who wanted to try something new, as evidenced by the laundry list of musicians from other genres who have tried their hand at the silver screen with similar results to the likes of Harry Styles or Taylor Swift (T.I., Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, Mick Jagger, Ludacris, Andre 3000, Roger Daltrey, Jack White, just as a few examples).

Also, J Lo was an actress first and shouldn’t be included in whatever this is.