Tin should be crucial

Yes, much of the tin used in the ancient Near East came from Afghanistan via overland trade. The Old Assyrian texts from Anatolia are explicit about tin being imported from Assyria via donkey caravans (which in turn imported it from further east), and the close association between lapis lazuli and tin in administrative and economic texts from trade hubs like Ebla likewise suggests that much (if not all) of the tin used in Anatolia and Mesopotamia came from Afghanistan.

Additionally, at least some tin was mined locally. For example, the Early Bronze Age Kestel tin mine was discovered in Turkey only about 30 years ago and suggests there's still a lot we don't know about early tin sources.

There has been a great deal of chatter about a recent study indicating tin came from Cornwall, but there are two issues with this study:

  • Virtually all of the ingots tested in the study came from shipwrecks in the eastern Mediterranean, with the exception of those found at Mochlos (an island off Crete), and thus the results are overwhelmingly and unsurprisingly skewed toward tin transported via ships in the Mediterranean.

  • The study focuses specifically on the Late Bronze Age, and we should not assume that Cornwall was already a significant source of tin in the Early and Middle Bronze Age.

/r/civ Thread Parent