Well, look. You gave me some feedback, you made a good point, and I agreed with you. I don't know why you chose to repeat that point to me. It's as if you're only interested in pointing out how much you know about the game, even at the cost of keeping a friendly and lively community which is open to sharing random ideas.

I'm not claiming that it's amazing or a fully baked idea, I really don't care that it wouldn't work in actual play for whatever reason. I can dream about whatever cards I want, I'm not asking you to play them.

I wouldn't say anything about this, but it frustrates me because I think people are often put off from sharing in this sub and joining the magic community as a whole because of people like you who feel the need to dish out heavy criticism to anyone who has an idea or is ignorant about some minute concept that isn't a major factor in gameplay.

Finally, I don't care what you say is or isn't correct about the game, because you're not an authority. The game is free to change season to season. Maybe planeswalkers are such and such now (as you see it) but the game is allowed to change its own rules and designs as it has many times in the past. If the game designers don't have the creative freedom to dream up new ideas and are limited to these rules you describe, then, in my opinion, the game would become stale and boring.

I need a drink. Sorry to be so defensive, but I've shared several ideas with this community on a whim, and each time I've been berated about the minute details by someone like you who misses fun and creativity of what I'm trying to share. So... this will be the last time I post here, thank you for that.