I never had any cringe experience like in that OG show. The weird hand sign was weird, period, and it tainted my enjoyment of that concert (and many others beside me), and their vocalist's demeanor was just so weirdly over the top, to the point where I found myself not listening to OG at all after this experience. Am I judging people in the pit for enjoying themselves or people from liking this band? not at all. Seems like they didn't notice or didn't care, and that's fine. Clearly others enjoy this, more power to them, but I am probably going to skip their set to go to the merch booth or something.

Also, I don't know where you're from, but in Montreal, mosh pits are intense affairs, and they stink, it's a fact. For example, in the Trivium show I went to recently, the entire first floor was a gigantic mosh pit, and there was a bad BO stink everywhere as a result. I was pretty happy to be on the 2nd floor for that one.

I feel like someone calling people on the 2nd floor douchebags is way more judgmental.