Former OC and CS instructor here. Been sprayed a few times, and been gassed so many times I can't remember. Can confirm OC is a lot worse than CS. Whereas CS doesn't really hurt, it's just uncomfortable, OC is extremely intense pain(had a former female soldier who claimed it hurt as bad as when she gave birth, although OC is localized, and giving birth is a whole body experience).
A little bit of information;
Lastly, a funny story; We once had sort of a "hell-day" for some soldiers. It was a long day, intense. When the day was coming to an end, I found an excess CS grenade at one of the last posts, and decided to give the squad I was instructor for a little extra. When we were in the middle of no-where, I took the grenade out held it behind my back, pulled the pin and showed it to them. I asked what it was, then said they had 15seconds(NATO standard to get masks on) before I threw the grenade. After 10-12 seconds I threw the grenade. But it malfunctioned, only sipping out a little bit of gas. I decided to rumble the grenade around a bit for it to burn better. I kicked it a bit, this was a mistake... And it "exploded" in the thickest cloud of CS I have ever seen. All my soldiers had masks on, the only one without a mask was me. I had been pestering the soldiers the whole day, and now they got to laugh a bit. It was all good fun. Oh, and the wind blew the way we were going.