Did anyone else feel like the new Hobbit trilogy was mostly flawless and the best adaptation of the book so far? I loved it and I've seen each movie at least 2-3 times (once in theater and sometimes on TV). It was exactly what my dream adaptation of a book is like - instead of cutting a lot out, it's long enough to have pretty much everything and retain the same pacing, and it even added in cool new stuff, especially the Gandalf side-story. Some people complained about the CGI too but I never noticed anything wrong with it - looked great to me both in 3D in the theater and in 2D on TV. I really don't have a single substantial complaint against it, and I've read the original twice and seen 2 or 3 different animated adaptations of the movie - I wrote a paper comparing them or something in an English class once. These three Hobbit movies plus the three LotR movies make a great 6 movie series. Yet another thing that's a 10/10 to me that everypony else on the internet hates I guess.

Did anyone else feel like the new Hobbit trilogy was mostly flawless and the best adaptation of the book so far? I loved it and I've seen each movie at least 2-3 times (once in theater and sometimes on TV). It was exactly what my dream adaptation of a book is like - instead of cutting a lot out, it's long enough to have pretty much everything and retain the same pacing, and it even added in cool new stuff, especially the Gandalf side-story. Some people complained about the CGI too but I never noticed anything wrong with it - looked great to me both in 3D in the theater and in 2D on TV. I really don't have a single substantial complaint against it, and I've read the original twice and seen 2 or 3 different animated adaptations of the movie - I wrote a paper comparing them or something in an English class once. These three Hobbit movies plus the three LotR movies make a great 6 movie series. Yet another thing that's a 10/10 to me that everypony else on the internet hates I guess.