"It's clear that this is a legitimate case of abduction, and the other scenarios that people have talked about are improbable"

"The fact that she was recovered alive such a long period of time after her initial disappearance, that really defies my experience with abduction cases"

So this guy says Sherri's disappearance was definitely an abduction, but then says in another breath that her reappearance is something he never sees, especially when someone is gone as long as she was???

Really, you care to make a wager on your belief?

Sherri was not abducted, she was picked up by a man she met on Tinder. When her disappearance made headlines, the man went back home, and Sherri did everything she could to make a kidnapping look legit.

Local LE is no longer investigating this case, mostly because the Papinis have not been cooperative.

Sherri wasn't on drugs, she was having an affair. Her husband, not knowing about the man she went to meet, filed a police report, and he ultimately showed no deception on a polygraph.

I may have heard all this from someone working in a local legal office setting.