Neither of you has any idea what you're talking about. Let me break it down for you.

• Supergirl: A story with lasting consequences evenly partitioned among Ben Lockwood and the Children of Liberty, Manchester Black and the Elite, and Lex Luthor, with Manchester tied to Lockwood and Lockwood tied to Luthor. Solid storytelling throughout, and incredible performances from David Ajala, David Harewood, Sam Witwer, Nicole Maines, Jesse Rath, Katie McGrath, Jon Cryer, Chyler Leigh, and Melissa Benoist. 9/10.
  • My other personal ratings for reference:
    • Season 3: 4/10
    • Season 2: 5/10
    • Season 1: 8/10
• The Flash: Orlin Dwyer gets beaten and flies away for sixteen episodes, then his niece travels back in time for no reason, kills him for no reason, and proceeds to go after Team Flash for no reason. They proceed to beat her a few times and watch her fly away until she doesn't. At least it's consistent. 6/10.
  • My other personal ratings for reference:
    • Season 4: 5/10
    • Season 3: 7/10
    • Season 2: 9/10
    • Season 1: 10/10
• Arrow: Incredible first seven episodes with Ricardo Diaz as the villain. Diaz continues as the main villain until Dante supersedes him in episode 13—just kidding. Oliver's sister is the bad guy. City's under attack? Must be May. 5/10.
  • My other personal ratings for reference:
    • Season 6: 6/10
    • Season 5: 8/10
    • Season 4: 2/10
    • Season 3: 7/10
    • Season 2: 10/10
    • Season 1: 10/10
• Legends: Eight random, completely disconnected misadventures until Hank is teased as a bad guy in episode 8—just kidding! Tom Wilson is so awesome that the writers decided that Hank was good all along, and Neron was the real bad guy, even though episode 8 teased that, too! Several unearned heartstring tugs. A nigh uncountable number of incredibly stupid haha funny gags. Sickening imagery of Adam Tsekhman with three nipples. A few bizarrely out-of-place gut punches involving Constantine. Woman we've never met before falls in love with an animal and becomes the main character on what's supposed to be an ensemble show for three episodes. Badass Time Bureau agent Ava Sharpe becomes a subdued housewife. Badass Waverider captain Sara Lance becomes a subdued, wisecracking housewife. Strong, independent Zari Tomaz suddenly can't coast through a season without a man by her side. Then, in the finale, the demon breaches its contract when it kills Nate after some Constantine ex machina, but no worries. He's brought back to life by a fucking kumbaya at the expense of one of the show's best characters. If my frustration bothers you, realize that you probably reacted the same way to Arrow season 4, which still ranks below this season's overall score of 3/10.
  • My other personal ratings for reference:
    • Season 3: 7/10
    • Season 2: 9/10
    • Season 1: 8/10

I fucking love Legends and always will, but season 4 was awful for me.