Those who think SA is guilty, what is the piece of evidence you consider most damning?

  1. He was the last person known to see TH. - FALSE Bobby saw her too...when you said 'last' you must attach time into argument;

  2. She was never seen after arriving at SA. - FALSE #1 must be proofed first;

  3. She never answered her phone after getting to SA.- FALSE you must have proof that her car never left SA property first;

  4. She reported that SA freaked her out. - no relevance TH visit SA 14-15 times. Looks like she wasn't much 'freaked out' if she keep coming back;

  5. He initially said that she never showed up at his place. - (in connection with #7), no relevance

  6. SA called her cellphone number later that day leaving a message asking where she was. - FALSE no message was left; call lasted 13-15 sec; voice mail greeting is longer

  7. SA later said oh no, she had in fact been there. - see #5

  8. TH car with SA blood in it. - RED FLAG!!! why no TH and SA blood mix found?

  9. TH car with SA dna under the hood. - no relevance evidence collection was flawed; lab technician didn't change gloves

  10. TH bones found in the burn pit intertwined with steel tire belts signifying that was burn location. - FALSE show me one picture where/how bones were found

  11. Bullet with TH dna on it found in SA garage. -no relevance evidence collection was flawed; lab technician contaminated this evidence

  12. Bullet was fired from SA gun. FALSE ballistic test were never performed

  13. TH car key found in SA bedroom. - FALSE personally, I love that key is under #13...hahaha...please be careful with word 'found'...:)...maybe in this case would be more appropriately to use word 'discovered':)

  14. TH phone and palm pilot found in burn barrel.- no relevancy do you know who owns this barrel? any fingerprints of someone who put these items there?

  15. TH tooth found in burn pit. - FALSE show me photo where it was found

  16. Rivet from the jeans that TH was wearing in burn pit. -FALSE show me photo where it was found

  17. BD confessed to the rape/murder. - DON'T YOU DARE talk about!!!

  18. BD stated things in the confession that only someone there would have known. -DON'T YOU DARE talk about!!!

  19. The DNA found under the hood was only looked for after BD stated what was done in his confession. - DON'T YOU DARE talk about!!!

  20. The bullet that was found was found because of what BD said in his confession. -DON'T YOU DARE talk about!!!

  21. BD stated that the two of them planned this for days. restraints used during the rape that BD described were recently purchased by SA. -DON'T YOU DARE talk about!!!

  22. TH car was found concealed in the Avery family salvage yard. TRUE

  23. BD also said he did it to his mother.-DON'T YOU DARE talk about!!!

  24. BD cousin reported to police that BD confessed taking part in the rape and murder.-DON'T YOU DARE talk about!!!

  25. BD was moody and sullen for months after this episode. He had lost significant weight and this prompted his cousin to ask him what was wrong. The cousin says this is when he confessed to her. -DON'T YOU DARE talk about!!!

  26. BD said they used bleach among other solvents to clean the garage. - DON'T YOU DARE talk about!!! I'm sick and tired to copy and paste...anything and everything related to BD 'confession' is 'false' and has 'no relevancy', period.

  27. BD mother had given statement that that night she saw bleach stains on BD clothes. no relevancy no TH blood was found in SA garage!!! PERIOD!!!!

OK...I'm done with your post...enjoy Nancy Grace!

/r/MakingaMurderer Thread Parent