You're right, I have made some very highly visible posts rationally criticizing the graphics (for example here and here ) or as you "shitting on the graphics", got thousands of upvotes and gold for giving evidence to my critcisms. I don't see how this is a bad thing, the game should be open to critical analysis.

As far as the game itself there are several problems: The size of the world, the combat (its literally copy pasted from Fallout 3), the graphics, the terrible story filled with cliches and the simplistic 2 choices they give you at the end, the way the choices you make in the game have almost no impact over the long term, the animation and dialogue and the AI come to mind. Every single quest has been essentially a fetch quest, only 3 I can remember tried to do something other than telling you to go somewhere, kill something/bring back an object from there. Since its using the same engine that bethesda has been using for year and since the last generation, everything feels incredibly similar. There are a lot of bugs too. Now all of those an be fixed by modders, but no amount of mods can fix what is fundamentally broken with the game: its shallow story and incredibly repetitive quests.

There are also good things, especially the crafting system. Its really well done and gives you tons of choices for how to make your weapon. The character customization is amazing, you can spend hours in the face molder and make exactly how you want yourself to look. The game runs smooth on PC, I've had no performance issues.

This will get me crucified with the fanboys as did my criticism of the games graphics in other threads, but fuck it.