I'm a big Solstice Scent's fan but since you're asking for advice on what to steer clear from I thought I could help. Of the ones you listed that I really love are Sarah Good and Cotton Mather.

I'm not a fan of their leather, which reads as much more chemical that SS's to me so something like Salem which I thought would be a huge hit I actually really disliked. I also cannot do anything that S92 lists almond because it reads as bathroom cleaner to me and a lot of her fruity/florals reads as soapy.

So unlike Solstice Scent's I've had way more misses with Sixteen92 than hits so I really recommend starting with a sample pack to see if they will even work for you. I have tried so much from this brand because the notes/aesthetic is what I love most, but sometimes brands just don't work for certain people.

Sarah Good, Cotton Mather, and Baba Yaga are definitely in that HG category for me though.