Ok so we're too deep in this to give up now and google didnt give me an answer and this is probably a million year old debate, so imma just post what i wrote and uh

Judaism is not an ethnicity as you claimed earlier, quite explicitly, and there is N . E . V . E . R . a worthwhile distinction to make there, as it only creates de-Judaizing distinctions that no generous/ educated Jew gives too much a fuck for, and your definition excludes like ~92% of Ashkenazi Jews who do not share DNA with those four Bar Kochba Revolt refugees who ended up at the rhine river who then protected the Ashkenazi line until sep 1st 2021, which is like naz! blood quantum? So should we just uh wrap this up?

Ps clearly i have time today