Absolutely. Unless of course this was staged and she had a rape fantasy and a safe word. Which this apparently was not the case here. I mean, I have a daughter and my main concern in this world is protecting her, so if I heard any HINT she might be getting threatened to be taken advantage of like this, there would be HELL to pay.

If my daughter or wife, alternatively, was saying they should have raped or drugged someone, I would shut that down real quick, too.

But while my first post may have sounded sarcastic, I was being completely serious. Obviously this girl did nothing wrong, whatsoever. After all, if she did do something wrong or was being dishonest, wouldn't we all know about it?

Yes what he said was very, very wrong. Good on OP for exposing that monster to all her friends. Jesus Christ, he said he should have raped her. You better believe I would not let my daughter around someone who said that.

Now, my wife and have some kind of freaky fetishes but those are completely private and in no way reflect who we are as protectors of our child. My ex-wife, on the other hand... She found men who was into this sort of stuff and got paid to live out these same fantasies my wife and I enjoy in the privacy of our home.

Ultimately I would say, good on this dude for being honest. Now this very good loyal girlfriend OP knows his intentions and can stay far away from him, unless she wants to safely an adult be freaky with OP. What he said was wrong and deserves scorn. If he had said this privately and she knew and was into this, and they had a safe word, and was just doing this for karma, that would be a wholllleeee other story.

Jesus,

Do you have any fetishes?