I was interested to see what wrestlers have picked up more negative match ratings according to WON, so I just decided to take a tally and post it here. Sorry if there's any errors in spelling or punctuation, it's currently 4:30am where I live and I'm going to sleep after I post this. If there's any interest I might complete the list to all matches with star ratings and not just the last 20 years.
(-1.5)(vs The Undertaker; Judgement Day 1998) (-1)(vs Big Show; King of the Ring 1999) (-1)( vs Big Show; Fully Loaded 1999) (-2)(w/ The Undertaker vs Brian Adams & Bryan Clark; Unforgiven 2001) (-1)(vs Big Show; Backlash 2006) (-1)(vs The Great Khali; Wrestlemania 23) (-1)(vs The Great Khali; Summerslam 2009) (-1)(vs The Great Khali; Breaking Point 2009)
(-1.5)(vs Hollywood Hogan; Souled Out 1997) (-1)(vs Kane; King of the Ring 1999) (-1)(vs Kane; Fully Loaded 1999) (-1)(vs Big Boss Man, Mideon, Prince Albert, Viscera; Survivor Series 1999) (-1)(vs Diamond Dallas Page; Rebellion 2001) (-1)(vs Kane; Backlash 2006) (-1*)(vs The Undertaker; Great American Bash 2006)
(-1.5)(w/ Henry O. Godwinn vs Mosh & Thrasher vs Blackjack Bradshaw & Blackjack Windham vs Doug Furnas & Phil LaFon; Wrestlemania 13) (-1.25)(w/ Henry O. Godwinn vs Jacques Rougeau & Pierre Ouellette; No Way Out of Texas 1998) (-1.5)(w/ Henry O. Godwinn in Tag Team Battle Royale; Wrestlemania XIV) (-1)(vs Big Boss Man; St. Valentine’s Day Massacare 1999) (-1)(w/ Big Boss Man, Prince Albert, Viscera vs Big Show; Survivor Series 1999) (-0.5)(vs William Regal; No Mercy 2000)
(-1)(w/ Shane Douglas vs Billy Kidman & Madusa; Fall Brawl 2000) (-1)(w/Lita vs Stacy Keibler & Mighty Molly; Rebellion 2001) (-1)(vs Dawn Marie; No Mercy 2002) (-1)(vs Sable; Great American Bash 2004) (-1)(vs Ashley Massaro, Candice Michelle, Maria Kanellis, Victoria; New Year’s Revoluion 2006) (-1)(vs Beth Pheonix, Michelle McCool, Kelly Kelly, Victoria, Layla, Jillian Hall, Brooke Adams, Kirstal Marshall, Maria Kanellis, Melina, Mickie James; Summerslam 2007)
(-1.5)(vs Steve McMichael; Halloween Havoc 1997) (-1)(vs Steve McMichael; World War 3 1997) (-1)(w/ Disco Inferno vs Johnny Grunge & Rocco Rock; Road Wild 1998) (-1)(vs Jim Duggan; Fall Brawl 1999) (-1*)(vs Vampiro; WCW Mayhem 1999)
(-1.5)(vs Farooq, Savio Vega; In Your House 17: Ground Zero) (-1.5)(w/ 8-Ball, Chainz, Skull vs Recon, Sniper, The Interrogator, The Jackyl; Survivor Series 1997) (-2)(vs Steve McMichael; Road Wild 1998) (-2)(w/ Bryan Clark vs Kane & The Undertaker; Unforgiven 2001) (-1*)(w/ Bryan Clark vs Ghost Walker & Navajo Warrior; WWA The Revolution)
(-1.5)(vs The Giant; Souled Out 1997) (-1.5)(vs Randy Savage; Uncensored 1998) (-1.25)(w/ Dennis Rodman vs Diamond Dallas Page & Karl Malone; Bash at the Beach 1998) (-4)(w/ Bret Hart & Stevie Ray vs Diamond Dallas Page, Roddy Piper, The Warrior vs Kevin Nash, Lex Luger, Sting; Fall Brawl 1998) (-5*)(vs The Warrior; Halloween Havoc 1998)
(-2)(vs Reggie White; Slamboree 1997) (-1.5)(vs Alex Wright; Halloween Havoc 1997) (-1)(vs Alex Wright; World War 3 1997) (-1)(vs Goldberg; Starcade 1997) (-2*)(vs Brian Adams; Road Wild 1998)
(-1)(vs Kane; Wrestlemania 23) (-1.5)(vs Batista; Summerslam 2007) (-1)(vs Dolph Ziggler; The Bash 2009) (-1)(vs Kane; Summerslam 2009) (-1*)(vs Kane; Breaking Point 2009)
(-1)(vs Berlyn; WCW Mayhem 1999) (-1.25)(vs Oklahoma; Starcade 1999) (-2)(vs Sting; Great American Bash 2000) (-2)(vs The KISS Demon; Bash at the Beach 2000) (-2.5*)(vs Mike Awesome; Halloween Havoc 2000)
(-2)(vs Balls Mahoney; Wrestlefest: 50 Years of Funk) (-1)(w/ D-Von Dudley vs Tommy Dreamer & The Sandman; Wrestlepalooza 1998) (-1)(w/ D-Von Dudley vs New Jack & Spike Dudley; Guilty As Charged 1999) (-1)(w/ D-Von Dudley vs Batista & Ric Flair; Royal Rumble 2004)
(-2)(vs Tori; Summerslam 1999) (-1)(vs The Fabulous Moolah; No Mercy 1999) (-1.5)(w/ Luna, Jacqueline, Terri vs Debra, Fabulous Moolah, Mae Young, Tori; Survivor Series 1999) (-1)(vs Chyna; Wrestlemania 17)
(-4)(w/ Sting, Kevin Nash vs Hulk Hogan, Bret Hart, Stevie Ray vs Roddy Piper, Diamond Dallas Page, The Warrior; Fall Brawl 1998) (-1)(vs Meng; WCW Mayhem 1999) (-1)(w/ Marcus Bagwell vs Chuck Palumbo & Sean O’Haire; WCW Greed 2001) (-0.5)(vs Sting; WWA The Retribution)
(-1.5)(vs Ashley Massaro; Royal Rumble 2006) (-1)(vs Lita; Cyber Sunday 2006) (-1)(vs Beth Pheonix, Michelle McCool, Kelly Kelly, Victoria, Layla, Jillian Hall, Brooke Adams, Kirstal Marshall, Maria Kanellis, Melina, Torrie Wilson; Summerslam 2007) (-1)(vs Winter; Hardcore Justice 2011)
(-1)(vs Umaga; Vengeance: Night of Champions) (-1)(vs Honky Tonk Man; Cyber Sunday 2008) (-2)(vs Vickie Guerrero & Chavo Guerrero; Extreme Rules 2009) (-1)(vs Ricardo Rodriguez; No Way Out 2012)
(-1)(vs Chavo Guerrero Jr.; Road Wild 1998) (-4)(w/ Bret Hart, Hulk Hogan vs The Warrior, Roddy Piper, Diamond Dallas Page vs Kevin Nash, Lex Luger, Sting; Fall Brawl 1998) (-1.5)(vs Konnan; World War 3 1998) (-1)(w/ Buff Bagwell vs Brian Christopher & Ernest Miller; WWA The Eruption 2002)
(-4)(w/ Lex Luger, Kevin Nash vs Hulk Hogan, Bret Hart, Stevie Ray vs Roddy Piper, Diamond Dallas Page, The Warrior; Fall Brawl 1998) (-2)(vs Vampiro; Great American Bash 2000) (-0.5)(vs Lex Luger; WWA The Retribution) (-1)(vs Jeff Hardy; Victory Road 2011)
(-2)(w/ Head vs Brian Christopher & Scott Taylor; King of the Ring 1998) (-3)(vs Big Boss Man; Unforgiven 1999) (-1.25*)(w/ Steve Blackman vs Albert & Test; Wrestlemania 2000)
(-1)(vs David Flair; Halloween Havoc 2000) (-1)(w/ Lex Luger vs Chuck Palumbo & Sean O’Haire; WCW Greed 2001) (-1*)(w/ Stevie Ray vs Brian Christopher & Ernest Miller; WWA The Eruption 2002)
(-1.25)(w/ Karl Malone vs Hollywood Hogan & Dennis Rodman; Bash at the Beach 1998) (-4)(w/ Roddy Piper, The Warrior vs Hulk Hogan, Bret Hart, Stevie Ray vs Kevin Nash, Lex Luger, Sting; Fall Brawl 1998) (-1*)(vs Big Show; Rebellion 2001)
(-1.5)(vs Crush, Savio Vega; In Your House 17: Ground Zero) (-1.5)(w/ Kama Mustafa in Tag Team Battle Royale; Wrestlemania XIV) (-1*)(vs The Rock; Over The Edge 1998)
(-1.5)(w/ Phineas I. Godwinn vs Mosh & Thrasher vs Blackjack Bradshaw & Blackjack Windham vs Doug Furnas & Phil LaFon; Wrestlemania 13) (-1.25)(w/ Phineas I. Godwinn vs Jacques Rougeau & Pierre Ouellette; No Way Out of Texas 1998) (-1.5*)(w/ Phineas I. Godwinn in Tag Team Battle Royale; Wrestlemania XIV)
(-1)(w/ Torrie Wilson vs Stacy Keibler & Mighty Molly; Rebellion 2001) (-1)(vs Jazz, Trish Stratus; Wrestlemania X8) (-1*)(vs Mickie James; Cyber Sunday 2006)
(-1.5)(w/Thrasher vs Blackjack Bradshaw & Blackjack Windham vs Henry O. Godwinn & Phineas I. Godwinn vs Doug Furnas & Phil LaFon; Wrestlemania 13) (-1.5)(w/Thrasher in Tag Team Battle Royale; Wrestlemania XIV) (-1*)(W/Thrasher vs Golga & Kurrgan; WWF Rock Bottom 1998)
(-1)(vs Daffney; Bash at the Beach 2000) (-2)(vs Major Gunns; WCW New Blood Rising 2000) (-1*)(w/ Mighty Molly vs Lita & Torrie Wilson; Rebellion 2001)
(-1)(vs The Wall; SuperBrawl 2000) (-1)(w/ Norman Smiley vs Lenny Lane & Rave; Uncensored 2000) (-2*)(vs Vampiro; Bash at the Beach 2000)
(-1.5)(vs Kane; Judgement Day 1998) (-2)(w/ Kane vs Brian Adams & Bryan Clark; Unforgiven 2001) (-1*)(vs Big Show; Great American Bash 2006)
(-1.5)(w/Mosh vs Blackjack Bradshaw & Blackjack Windham vs Henry O. Godwinn & Phineas I. Godwinn vs Doug Furnas & Phil LaFon; Wrestlemania 13) (-1.5)(w/Mosh in Tag Team Battle Royale; Wrestlemania XIV) (-1*)(W/Mosh vs Golga & Kurrgan; WWF Rock Bottom 1998)
(-2)(vs Sable; Wrestlemania XV) (-2)(vs Ivory; Summerslam 1999) (-1.5*)(w/ Debra, Mae Young, Fabulous Moolah vs Ivory, Terri, Luna, Jacqueline; Survivor Series 1999)