I love Mitch, and I truly think he wanted to vote for Kelsey but genuinely couldn't because her horrible answer. Maddy is catty and petty and WOULD NEVER had voted for Kelsey in any equation. I don't know for sure why Tim since he lies a lot lol but I've heard Nikki say on the show and post that the Brothers were good kids. I know she liked Nick at least. Joel is weird, I agree but I think as a "gamebot" he couldn't justify voting for Kelsey. I don't think he wanted to vote for The Bro's. Cass must have been pissed that Kelsey turned on her and voted her out, plus her speech was kind of condescending to Cass the way she said "And Cassandra will be leaving today" or something like that. The Bros did berate her, and they don't like her (I met Phil and he pretty much told me lol) but she said even on the feeds this season that she loves the Bro's and thinks that they're "sweet boys". Mitch, Cass, Tim, Nikki and Joel didn't want The Bros to win, but did over Kelsey. Phil was delusional, but Nick was likeable and honest with Cass and some people with his mental health issues which I think tbh made him endearing to Cass. People liked Nick, and he won comps, and Kelsey's speech was the worst ever. That's why they won. Kelsey > Phil (post-jury) but Nick > Kelsey. We'll agree to disagree I guess lol :)