usually the fat guy saying "That can't be done" or "If you do that, then X will necessarily be a consequence" is ALWAYS wrong.

Mate I think you'll find that I'm the fat guy who cautions against knee-jerk changes to things that aren't already broken/unsatisfactory until the consequences have been thoroughly explored.

I'm certainly not the guy who ignores 80% of the post he's responding to so he can sling insults at the opposing party.

Beyond that; you seem to be confusing "could" with "should". I never said that any of this couldn't function, I said it shouldn't be implemented and outlined why I think that is. Not all change is good, and trying to use this straw man you've constructed of a fat pessimist doesn't help you establish that this change is.

Finally; of the two of us you're the only one who's waved his occupation around, as though that makes anything you've said carry more weight. You're the only one who's repeatedly ignored a great deal of what the other has said. You're the only one who's traded in insults.

You don't look good, you look like an immature, serial contrarian who's incapable of letting an argument on reddit go after more than 2 days.