Wow really long comment.

Your argument essentially boils down to this. Because players are choosing to play in the NCAA rather than other avenues it must provide them more value. Because it provides them more value the NCAA must be a moral organization. You aren’t really presenting “facts.” You are presenting a philosophical argument of sorts. It’s really more of a tautology. IE the NCAA provides more total value to the players because the players are choosing to go to the NCAA. I just disagree that you have proven this is an ethical and moral arrangement through only the force of your own logic. That’s it.

You actually don’t have very much knowledge at all of the NCAA as an organization. As I said, there is a lot of good critiques of the NCAA out there for you to take a look at. My concerns go beyond just monetary compensation for the games. Take a breath, then google a bit.