(PSA)Su:m 37 Miracle Rose Cleansing Stick VS. So Natural Facial Cera Stick Cleanser

Hello everyone! There was a post here a while ago if anyone had tried the SO NATURAL CLEANSING STICK. I ordered about three weeks ago from TK and just received it. Thank you ems, because I am impatient which also leads me to post this.

UNFORTUNATELY I couldn't take photos of the stick twisted up because I broke it. (Here is a con for this stick - when I first tried to twist it up the stick wouldn't go back down so I pushed it down. MY MISTAKE BECAUSE I guess I was too harsh and now I can't twist it back up. Oh well might have to order another)

I will post a part two when I've used both cleansing sticks for a few more weeks. But I thought I'd share my thoughts on it so far.
FIRST IMPRESSIONS
SU:M 37 MIRACLE ROSE CLEANSING STICK
SCENT - I'm awful at differentiating scents but it does smell like roses. Packaging - Functionality it's really well made, I could twist it up and down with a problem. Texture - Applying it on the face it's soft and the petals aren't harsh on the skin. Lathers well. Efficiency - I have not used it to remove makeup but it does make my face feel clean without feeling dry and after my skin feels quite soft. Price - Fluctuates a bit, but it's not sold out or discontinued.

SO NATURAL DEEP MOISTURE CERAFOCUS FACIAL CERA STICK CLEANSER
SCENT - First had a hint of roses not it smells lemony or citrusy. Packaging - Functionality it's okay but my stick won't twist up at all. Texture - I used a bubble net to apply it on my face. I felt and rubbed the petals and they aren't harsh. Also lathers well. Has more of a marshmallow foam then MRCS. Efficiency - I have not used it to remove makeup but it also makes my face feel clean without feeling dry or tight and after my skin feels so smooth. This one feels a lot more moisturizing then the MRCS Price - Pretty cheap

NOW ONTO THE PH STRIP TEST!
AS EVERYONE KNOWS THE SU:M 37 MIRACLE ROSE CLEANSING STICK IS A 5.5 I WITH A HEAVY HEART HAVE TO INFORM THAT THE SO NATURAL FACIAL CERA CLEANSING STICK IS A 7 BUT TO BE SAFE BETWEEN A 7-7.5.
I will retest in the morning for more clear photos as testing it to remove makeup.

A bit confusing because the so natural stick feels more moisturizing then the su:m 37 miracle cleansing stick.

Hopefully this will help you sleep better again if anyone wants more photos please ask I will retest with ph strips but it looks it won't change.

/r/AsianBeauty Thread Link - imgur.com