Odyssey is an INCREDIBLE game, and I'm still attempting to 100% it. Right now I am feeling like OP is...it feels like a real grind to collect these moons. I was really excited once I collected 500 moons, because of the big challenge at the end of the game. However, I ended up completing it really easily, and what I thought was going to be an epic test of skill like the Master Trials was ended up being a "oh ok that was pretty cool" moment for me instead of a "OMG I CAN'T BELIEVE I ACTUALLY BEAT THIS" moment. I am currently using my two amiibo to get moon hints to finish the game, which just feels like a grind at this point and isn't super fulfilling.

I guess I'll leave it at that and say that while both are incredible, BOTW is my game of the year over Mario.