Pulling from various PS4 just complicates matters for me (as does having a glass of Scotch or 3, so forgive me)...

I can appreciate a good story and it's better than a bad one, but it's not why I game. I primarily go to books and Tv series when I want a good story. The only story I typically need in a game is something passable enough to not break immersion from the gameplay and world it's in... Less is often more. I don't need to know why the world collapsed and if you can't tell it well than don't bother telling it at all.

Music is a non-issue. I always turn it off. "My game" would have amazing sound design and ambience, from which music would be a distraction. I don't like "mood music" or musical cues, I feel they're artificially manipulative and immersion killing. I'd much rather hear flies buzzing, leaves crushing, shells pinging, birds chirping, character breathing, etc, etc, etc.

My dream game would be something like Day Z, in first person only, with AAA budget/visuals/polish. If I were to mention any PS4 games, I'd go with the world/enviroments of The Division or Dying Light.

... Dying Light without the parkour, focus on melee combat and "super zombies"... Instead as a hardcore tactical shooter? That'd be pretty amazing. Or The Division as a realistic FPS, without the RPG combat? Yes please.

I guess it boils down to... AAA budget/visuals/polish, Co-op/PvP, realistic tactical FPS, in an open world that's at least partially urban.