AITA For not responding super amused when she compliments other guys?

There isn't really a lot to say. but we haven't spoke in like a couple of minutes right after I explained that nothing was wrong. i simply said like. "Look, I don't know how you want me to reply on this. This is pretty much a basic response." But before this she was thinking like I was upset or mad that she's bringing them up. And of course I was confused like "what?"

Do I have to act like overly amused how you're talking about other guys in general? I mean, I have nothing against it. But I won't really act excited or anything like that. But also, i'm not a jealous person. If I were, I would probably comment on everything she's been doing with other guys. It's just her behavior is really strange when it comes to situations like this

/r/AmItheAsshole Thread Parent