3. If determinism is true, then we have free will

If determinism is true, then we have free will

If we suppose determinism is true, then you just are the sum total of a whole bunch of prior causes: all the genetic and environmental factors that caused you to have certain beliefs, values, desires, and so on. So if you choose, we cannot suppose that these force you to choose.

I believe you've presupposed that we've already made a choice, and that therefore we have free will. You have to prove the individual made a choice first, and then you can derive wherever that choice came from.

Speaking of Compatibility though:

The argument I'm about to make is complete scientific quackery, but I believe it makes sense. From an empirical standpoint, if we assume Free Will exists, then we can also assume there's a part of the brain that's responsible for Free Will. The Free Will part of the brain sends an electrical signal to the motor complex, which then moves your arm. In your example, you can be Compatible because if someone shocked your motor cortex, you would be aware that you didn't control it. What would happen if someone shocked the Free Will part of your brain? Could you still be a Compatibilist?

I think the easiest argument against what I just said is "the brain doesn't work like that." But I believe anyone, who's not a Dualist, that asserts Free Will can arise from something physical has to admit that there's a portion of the brain responsible for Free Will.

/r/philosophy Thread
Previous
Next

Recently removed from /r/philosophy

Miyamoto Musashi's philosophy of "winning without fighting" is a central theme throughout his lif. This idea involves using intelligence and understanding of the situation to achieve victory without resorting to violence. From Self-Harm to Terrorism: Unveiling the Potential Misuse of ChatGPT for Enabling Harmful Conversations and Illicit Actions How Americans Define Truth Boenhoffer's Theory of Stupidity argues that it is more an enemy of the Good than Malice because while "one may protest against evil; it can it can be exposed and prevented by the use of force, [but] against stupidity we are defenceless...Reasons fall on deaf ears". The Dark Aspect of Therapy The afterlife is in our heads: consciousness and near-death experiences The moral implications of building true AIs It’s comforting to think those who disagree with our beliefs are simply irrational. But that isn’t the case. Many complex factors motivate beliefs, and properly understanding them is vital. Mike Huemer: Abortion Is Difficult We do what we do because of who we are. We can’t be ultimately morally responsible for what we do without also being responsible for who we are, which is impossible | Galen Strawson. Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, and the meaning of suffering | Every life contains a good deal of suffering, what counts is how we respond to it - our best course of action might be to laugh. Suicide prevention laws are functionally the same as blasphemy laws In Support of a Fundamental Right to Die: an argument from personal liberty None of us are entirely self-made. We must recognise what we owe to the communities that make personal success possible. – Michael Sandel on the tyranny of merit. Scientists are fraught with errors, biases and conflicts of interest, but the only thing that beats science is better science.

More Random Comments

Europeans and other non-americans, how are things in your country's media? How to ask my boyfriend for a break without breaking up and ruining our relationship? Which brand of disk do you recommend? I let my coworker touch me even though I'm engaged. Psychological Depression, Don't Know What To Do [DISCOUNT ETIQUETTE] Regular is insistent on a reduced rate Not sure if I should confront hairstylist. Please help! In Zathura (2005) the Zorgon spaceship has victory markings showing how many houses it has destroyed. Possibly quitting breastfeeding due to intolerances Discussion Thread Have any of youse lost a substantial amount of weight and actually feel worse now? how long does weed smell stay on you inside Raising Kanan - 2x07 "No Love Lost" - Episode Discussion Advice needed AITA for facetiming my husband so our toddler could talk to him during his brother’s bachelor party?