The whole North Pole was fucked up in that movie. Rudolph was ostracized for being different. Hermey's dream of being a dentist was mocked by the other elves. Unwanted toys were banished to a secluded island. Santa, the reindeer, and the elves eventually accept them, but only after our misfits save the day.

Now, here's what should've happened. After Rudolph and Hermey run off, they vow to take their revenge on everyone who has wronged them. They go on a quest to recruit others to their cause, to this end joining forces with Yukon Cornelius and the residents of The Island of Misfit Toys. They even manage to ally with the Abominable Snowman, or Bumble, who is promised free rein in the North Pole for his assistance.

Rudolph, Hermey, and their army of misfits return to Santa's workshop and show no mercy. Unprepared for such an onslaught, the reindeer and the elves fall one by one as the pent up rage of the misfits is unleashed upon them. In the end, no survivors are left and Santa's discriminatory reign is at an end. The story concludes with Rudolph surveying the mass of corpses drenched in blood, feeling a twisted pleasure as he realizes that, now, the whole North Pole is red.