a guy is giving a point as to why he preffers seeing multiple versions.
Incomplete sentence
"You come saying that neither the game or this artist did it justice"
Ok yes I did
"like your version was the definitive"
Draw what ever conclusions you like but me not liking a piece of art does not mean I claim to have a better version or that I have a 'definitive' version it just means I don't like it.
"there are ways to do art critic."
Incomplete sentence
"That is sitting on a high horse"
Guy doesn't like this drawing clearly he has a chip on his shoulder.? What a joke
Reading a bit of your comment history I have not desire to respond to anything else you say you keep trying to draw conclusions preach your 'knowledge' to people a question was asked "Why do people want replicas" I answered the question with why the particular art does not sit right with me and then you respond to my answer calling it bullshit and then trying to teach about art.
Lets go back to your original comment shall we?
Books are considered by artists one of the best ways to create a "visual gallery" what is a visual gallery? a set of images or details that don't require a direct reference and are all taken from the atist imagination in order to make something new.
Just explaining art
"The reason for this is because books are never set in stone, people are open to create their own image from the words used."
Just explaining art still nothing of merit.
"You like the version of yennefer YOU imagined"
Yes i do
" there is no such thing as a yennefer in real life"
No way? Damn
"words can't plasmate that and never will."
Incomplete sentence?
"It's up to the artist to take that and create his own vision. CDPR took that and made one themselves,"
Yep still explainig art
"you'll never be satisfied unless you make one YOURSELF."
No I'm just not satisfied with 2 images from this subreddit as i said drawing baseless conclusions.
All you really said is
Thats bullshit, you don't know art, art is this, these people did art, if you don't like it why don't you do art.