I think it's extremely damaging to her. Years ago when the edited audio first came out, I thought it made her sound like a monster. The full context later was released and I understood where she was coming from a lot more.

I do admit though that there are two audios that make her sound terrible, particularly the one where she says I wasn't punching you I was hitting you and the one where she says she gets so mad sometimes she just loses it.

And it looks like both Amber and Johnny were not fully honest on the stand, either intentionally or just through bad memory of certain facts.

Either way, ultimately I just think that she was a mentally unstable and imperfect victim but that doesn't negate her story in my mind.