Yeah. The logic behind it is that it's NOT okay for white people take things from historically oppressed groups. But the oppressed groups are only allowed to be brown/black people. For example, I named my white/Mexican child a STRAIGHT UP Jewish name. This is okay for some reason, even though Jews are a historically oppressed minority. (I mean, the holocaust for gods sake.) or if you argue that Italians were an oppressed minority upon immigrating to the US in the early 1900's, therefore anyone who eats spaghetti that is not Italian is culturally appropriating... this argument isn't valid either. The logic doesn't make sense and is inherently racist and segregating in itself.