Well, here's my list:
Anime Title Score Type Progress 1 Steins;Gate 10 TV 24 2 Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 10 TV 64 3 Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch R2 10 TV 25 4 Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch 10 TV 25 5 Ergo Proxy 9 TV 23 6 Mirai Nikki (TV) 9 TV 26 7 Psycho-Pass 2 9 TV 11 8 Tsubasa: Shunraiki 9 OVA 2 9 Tsubasa: Tokyo Revelations 9 OVA 3 10 Fate/Zero 2nd Season 9 TV 12 11 Psycho-Pass 9 TV 22 12 Death Note 9 TV 37 13 Jormungand 9 TV 12 14 Fate/Zero 9 TV 13 15 Code Geass: Boukoku no Akito 2 - Hikisakareshi Yokuryuu 8 Movie 1 16 Guilty Crown 8 TV 22 17 Jormungand: Perfect Order 8 TV 12 18 Death Parade 8 TV 12 19 Code Geass: Boukoku no Akito 1 - Yokuryuu wa Maiorita 8 Movie 1 20 Fullmetal Alchemist: The Conqueror of Shamballa 8 Movie 1 21 Densetsu no Yuusha no Densetsu 8 TV 24 22 Durarara!! 7 TV 24 23 Fullmetal Alchemist 7 TV 51 24 Sword Art Online II 7 TV 24 25 No Game No Life 7 TV 12 26 Danganronpa - The Animation 7 TV 13 27 Tsubasa Chronicle 7 TV 26 28 Tsubasa Chronicle 2nd Season 7 TV 26 29 Sword Art Online 7 TV 25 30 Trinity Blood 7 TV 24 31 .hack//Roots 6 TV 26 32 Black Bullet 6 TV 13 33 Baccano! 6 TV 13 34 Durarara!!x2 Shou 6 TV 12 35 Steins;Gate: Fuka Ryouiki no Déjà vu 2 Movie 1 Nope-list:
Title 1 Kiseijuu 2 Elfen Lied
What do you suggest then? Black Butler? Higashi no Eden? Zetsuen no Tempest?