You and OP both nailed him. The only time he's ever been funny to me is when he's being made fun of. He has that "I used to be fat, but now I'm not so I'm tough" energy that a lot of former fat guys get. Like not eating as much sweet treats and walking more somehow makes then Francis Ngannou. Dude is a try hard idiot.

Dave Smith just regurgitates Libertarian shit he reads on the internet while fellating himself as some sort of deep political thinker. The fact that there's dumbasses on the Rogan sub who think he's a legitimately intelligent political strategist who should run for office is hilarious. He's the least funny guy on an extremely mediocre podcast. What an accomplishment.

Jay is legitimately funny. I haven't listened to The Bonfire in years, but for the first couple of years I listened to every episode and he's a real one. Him and Soder mesh extremely well, but Soder works well with just about anybody. Him acting like such a fucking bitch these last few weeks has been disappointing to see. He's clearly still got self esteem issues he needs to work on.