You’re missing the point lol.

If a diamond thief steals a $60,000 diamond from a safe and then turns around and sells it for $50,000 on the black market do you think he’s a good person?

If I commissioned an artist to paint me a picture of a cat for $20, and then after I receive the painting I charge back the payment and sell the painting to someone else, that’s okay?

Plex shares aren’t some dude selling his dvd collection. Most of the paid servers have like 4000 movies and 4000 tv shows. Are you going to give them the benefit of the doubt and say those were all legitimately acquired?

Selling access to something that you acquired for free is shitty. The whole point people pirate is because they don’t wanna pay the price themself. And then they turn around and charge someone else for the same thing.

That’s not Hypocritical?

Should I go rent books from my public library for free and then put them up on Craigslist for 50 bucks? I mean I went through the trouble of walking to the library and renting the books so I should be paid for my service.