Stalin everyone.

"The reason why I pointed out Rummel’s interesting past is because someone who claims to be against the killing of innocents, probably shouldn’t support the killing of innocents just because it’s their side doing the killing. This puts their intentions and reliability into question".

Thats is like someone saying "drunk driving is bad" then trying to call them out as a hypocrite by saying well "Well i've seen you go over the speed limit so..." it's a weak argument if you want call his credibility and intentions into question. Millions supported the war on terror from both common citizens and intellectuals. He didn't support the war to kill innocents, when did he ever say or support that? I'll answer it for you, he didn't. You're not going to go far with that argument. I just think you're upset that his work brings to light the terrible atrocities that have occurred on socialist regimes so you're grasping at every excuse you can to apologise for the act of despots and discredit those who call them out for their actions.

"I would never just trust what the Soviets published since they would never publish something that makes them look bad, but these records were kept as classified and not intended to be released. Because of this there was no reason for them to tamper with the data since they didn’t expect to collapse and have them be released to the public. Their record keeping could be compared to the Nazis, they would record everything possible for future analysis. The only difference is that they didn’t destroy 90% of them to avoid being charged with war crimes"

"I would never just trust what the Soviets published since they would never publish something that makes them look bad"

No shit...

"but these records were kept as classified and not intended to be released. Because of this there was no reason for them to tamper with the data since they didn’t expect to collapse and have them be released to the public."

Or the USSR didn't want the world to see how fucked up of a country it was and didn't want to face the seaver backlash from other countries for their atrocities from being brought to light and that their ideology was a massive and murderous failure so they can maintain power of their people? Because that is what every totalitarian police state does.

/r/Libertarian Thread Parent Link - i.redd.it