Seriously, I had this exact problem a week ago. Called the plumber. There are a lot of DIY things I'll do, but plumbing (and electrical) are where I'm calling a pro.
Of course, the plumber couldn't make it for almost a week. So I looked into it on YouTube. One trip to Home Depot and about $20 later, it took me 20 minutes to replace.
It's seriously just:
That many steps makes it seem more complicated than it is. It's actually really easy.