They're is no P2W Genshin has no competitive aspect so that aint an argument.

"Through and through gacha " , Ok what's not about a Gacha about creating an Anni banner , giving them rewards and letting them spend them / spend Even more as You said " Big incentive comes from discount packs" and they just happened to reset top ups.

And If you're going to Say It wouldnt be limited , You could put Yae there , it could be a rerun like I said How Many people are still thirsting for Albedo? ??Hutao???

This is the thing that I hate about your argument that : "Oh they do other games , what about it".

Mihoyo learened a lot, and what i'm telling You is just a simple math.

Give rewards , put a banner, people are going to put money on them , people werent doing it before.

It's also like always the Best time to bring New people, specirally those that we're on the fence.