If this is a season long anthology show, I got enough suggestions for like 6 more seasons.
Happy Appy (Another creepypasta about a lost kids show. The first creepypasta I ever read.)
Penpal (Need I say more)
Jeff the Killer (Judge me all you like. I think Jeff the Killer is creepy and has enough material to make a good detective story.)
The SCP Foundation (With the numerous entities recorded in the SCP archives, this would make an interesting series of origin stories about how the SCP Foundation detained them leading up to a finale that's basically Containment Breech. This is what I'd REALLY like to be covered the most in future seasons.)
1999 (yet another messed up kids show, this is the first creepypasta that actually gave me a real feeling of dread, and combine that with children death and it'd make for an interesting season.
AND LAST BUT CERTAINLY NOT LEAST!!
Also, I like the idea of a creepypasta anthology show. There are a lot of good stories that would make pretty good episodes If they did like Tales From The Crypt and covered one story per episode. A season seems like it'd drag on a bit too long, so I'm a bit iffy on Channel Zero.
However, I heard that Machinima is working on a creepypasta anthology show, AND they're teaming up with Clive Barker for it! And on top of that, the reboot of Tales From The Crypt is going to the Internet in order to find ideas for episodes! So a creepypasta anthology show really isn't impossible, it just has to be done right. And I only hope Max Landis knows what he's doing.