It wasn't as awesome as everyone made it sound. For starters, I was aiming way too high, so she had to help me out there. She was very tight, so I didn't think that it would fit, but she kept assuring me that it would, so I kept pushing. Since I didn't know jack shit about foreplay, my foreskin pulled back to the point of hurting. Finally I managed to get in there. When I pushed in, she yelled "oh!" and she looked like she was in pain, so I stopped and asked her if she was ok. She said "Push!" so I started going again.

I guess that I was expecting this overwhelming pleasure to start as soon as I got it in. That was not the case. I remember thinking "this is it?"

One thing that I didn't expect was the smell. Now she didn't smell bad or anything, I had just never smelled pussy before. I also found out that the smell stays on you for a while. Nobody ever told me about that part.

When I came, I had no idea where to put it. So I'm asking her where she wants it. She said "inside, don't worry I'm on the pill". So I finished up inside of her. After that, I was desperate to find something to clean up with. She got me some paper towels, and I did the best that I could with them. But my cock was still kind of sticky.

After I left, I felt dirty. I didn't love this girl or anything, I just wanted to get laid like everyone else. It was not at all what I was expecting. I thought that sex was supposed to be this amazing thing that I was missing out on, but instead I found it to be very overrated. Fortunately she didn't get pregnant, because at 13 years old, I would have been a terrible father.

Tldr: Hurt my dick putting it into very tight, unprepared pussy. Smelled pussy for the first time. Came inside. Felt dirty as hell afterwards. 3/10, should have waited.