So it's pretty to look at, has a great world (only.gameplay thing you mention), and has great characters. Sounds like you had fun. That's nice, but can't I enjoy those elements.of the game for free on YouTube? It sounds identical to the first game, which was also good to look at, had a great open world, and had great characters, but those things are vital to a great movie. I'm assuming the gameplay is identical to rdr1, cover shooting with bullet time.

Glad you like it, but it does not belong on the #1 spot on a game list imo. An experience list, a story list, a TV show list, sure. Play more games if you think this is a.masterpiece, you've missed out on more than a few that excell at gameplay.

And don't worry, I expect lots of downvotes. Idc. Truth is truth. It's a really popular game and lots of people love it, i.dont like cinematic movie games personally. I watch them for free on YouTube.